I never told TikTok what kind of women I find attractive. I never searched for it, typed it, or described it. And yet, scroll after scroll, it shows me exactly that kind of woman. Not just women in general. My type, with an accuracy that sometimes stops me mid-scroll.
The first time I noticed it, I was impressed. The second time, I was a little scared. I’m still not sure which feeling is the right one.
The Strategy I Thought I Had
My relationship with social media is complicated. I’m careful about what I share. I don’t post pictures of myself, my location, where I’ve been, or the details of my personal life. To anyone looking at my profiles, there isn’t much to see.
But that doesn’t mean I share nothing. I share my interests, on purpose: what I like, what I don’t like, what holds my attention. I know the information I feed these platforms shapes what they learn about me, what they show me, and, ultimately, what reaches my mind.
So I curate. I engage with what I want more of. I block accounts that waste my time. I treat every like, follow, and skip as an instruction. The deal, as I saw it, was simple: they get my interests, not my life, and in return they give me a feed worth my time.
I’m in control of that deal. But TikTok showed me just how far it can go.
TikTok: The One That Knows Too Much
On one level, TikTok understands me in a way I truly appreciate. It knows I’m hungry for knowledge. It knows I love philosophy, psychology, computer engineering, and the sciences. It knows I love debates, the kind where different people bring different perspectives, challenge each other, disagree, and leave me thinking. I built that feed deliberately, and TikTok learned it well.
But it learned something I never taught it. Somewhere between the debates and the lectures, it figured out what I find attractive. Sometimes the two worlds meet: a woman who is exactly my type, explaining an idea I find fascinating. In those moments, the algorithm seems to know me almost completely.
It’s one thing for a platform to understand my academic interests. I actively searched for those; I trained it on purpose. It’s another thing for it to understand my romantic preferences, which I never put into words, not to it, and barely to myself.
I find this both impressive and frightening. Impressive, because it shows how much a system can learn from behavior alone. Frightening, because I have to ask: if it worked that out without my ever spelling it out, what else has it worked out?
Instagram: The One I Had to Teach
Instagram understands me differently, mostly because I had to teach it everything it knows.
It knows my type in women, but only because I showed it on purpose. I engaged with the accounts I liked, ignored the ones I didn’t, and slowly shaped its recommendations until they matched my preferences. It learned, but it learned the way a student does: through direct instruction.
The same is true of my intellectual interests. Instagram knows a little about what I like to learn, but only what I’ve deliberately trained into it, and I still have to keep teaching. It learns what I tell it, and not much more.
In a way, Instagram is the platform that fits my original strategy best. I decide what to show it, and it learns exactly that. No surprises.
Which is exactly what makes TikTok so different. Instagram had to be taught my type. TikTok just knew.
X: The One That Forgot Me
Twitter used to understand me remarkably well. It didn’t just match my interests; it directed my attention. It introduced me to ideas, arguments, and conversations I didn’t know I wanted until I was in the middle of them. It knew how to keep me thinking.
That’s no longer my experience. My feed on X now feels random, as though the platform is showing me whatever it can find rather than what I care about. Maybe the algorithm changed after Elon Musk acquired it. Maybe I changed how I use it. Either way, the platform that once understood me best now seems not to know me at all.
What it does show me now, more and more, is pictures of attractive women. And that tells me something. When an algorithm loses track of who you are, this is apparently where it falls back: the easiest, most universal signal it has. It makes me look at TikTok’s accuracy differently, too. Maybe part of what feels like deep understanding is just the easiest signal in the world, sharpened by everything else I’ve shown it.
X is a text platform. What I want from it is ideas: arguments, debates, perspectives that challenge or expand how I think. Pictures were never the point. The old Twitter knew that. The new X doesn’t.
Facebook: Proof That My Strategy Works
Facebook is practically useless to me, and for a long time I thought that was Facebook’s failure. Now I think it’s my success.
Facebook was built on your social life: your friends, your family, your photos, your updates, where you’ve been. That’s exactly what I don’t share. TikTok runs on what you watch; Facebook runs on who you are and who you know. I gave Facebook almost nothing about who I am, so it has almost nothing to work with.
In a strange way, Facebook is the only platform where my privacy strategy fully worked. It’s also the only one that offers me nothing.
What My Attention Tells Them
Put these platforms side by side and a pattern appears. I keep my face, my location, and my personal life to myself. My attention is the thing I give away, and I give it on purpose.
None of it is accidental. What I watch, what I skip, what I rewatch, how long I pause: these are choices. I know they reveal what I want, because that is exactly why I make them. A picture would only show what I look like. My attention shows what I want, and what I want is the only thing I’m interested in teaching these platforms.
So I’m not surprised that TikTok learned my type. I gave it the signals. What fascinates me is how much it built from them. I gave it moments, a few seconds here and there, and it put them together into a picture of my type more precise than one I could have described myself. I never said it out loud. It worked it out.
And honestly, I like that. It’s the deal working better than I expected.
What I Actually Want
There’s a contradiction in me I can’t ignore. I miss the old Twitter because it knew how to steer my attention toward ideas I didn’t know I needed. And I’m uneasy with TikTok because it knows me so well. But those are the same power. A system that can guide your attention has to know you first. I can’t ask to be understood well enough to be led, and then be surprised that I’ve been understood.
Maybe what I really want isn’t less understanding, but a say in it: to be known on my terms, for the things I choose to show.
Every interaction is part of a feedback loop. The platform watches what I do, predicts what I want, shows it to me, and learns from how I respond. Over time, it becomes better and better at holding my attention, because it has learned which ideas, which people, and which subjects I can’t resist.
That’s why I’ll keep being deliberate. I don’t want social media to know my life. I want it to understand my mind well enough to show me what’s worth seeing. But I’ve learned that the line between my mind and my life is thinner than I thought. And when a platform begins to predict things I never told it, I find myself caught between admiration for the technology and a quiet question about what that understanding costs me.
Comments